watchers keep bg2. BG2 Question - Watcher's Keep. watchers keep bg2

 
BG2 Question - Watcher's Keepwatchers keep bg2 Hello, my character's name is Kerrigan and she is a fighter (lvl 24) with GM in Long Sword/Shortbow and I assure you she has the best gear

BG2, BGT, BG2:EE and EET: - Adds a powerful longbow somewhere to the third level of Watcher's KeepY'tossi is a marilith that appears on the 5th level of Watcher's Keep. However, since you can get some ridiculously good loot just from the vendor lady + Level 1-2, it’s possible to use Watchers’ Keep to make SoA a lot easier. If you go to the Watcher's Keep at a relatively low level, there will be less statues guarding the gate to the second level. So far, so good. Another can be looted in the Ice Mage's library. Open my documents and find the baldurs gate folder. It will agree to open the portal to the next level, if you free it from its prison. Don't install or reinstall this component while you're exploring the maze. 3 - 3. Normally I do it after leaving Saradush. Watcher's Keep can be done as early as Chapter 2 in BG2. Baldurs Gate II: Shadows of Amn & Throne of Bhaal: 11: 09-14-2004 05:31 AM: Ice Golem (Watchers Keep) Big_Daddy02: Baldurs Gate II: Shadows of Amn & Throne of Bhaal: 4: 10-02-2003 05:59 PM: To Kill a Crystal Golem: Dmouse: Icewind Dale | Heart of Winter | Icewind Dale II Forum: 2: 10-02-2002 12:13 PM: How to I kill the Crystal. Map of the 3rd level of Watchers Keep for Baldurs Gate II: Throne of Bhaal. They offer a lot of gold. Inside this chamber, you'll encounter two mind flayers, an ulitharid, and two umber hulks. See All. Tried every combo I could think of. True, but still, BG2 is still a pretty damn hard rpg regardless of how strong you are, especially by today's standards. Acemandoo, Aug 8, 2001. Some years ago, I finished Watcher's Keep in late Chapter 3, with a party of six characters in their mid-teens. Keep the hard hitters away from your archers while they do their job, and use Jaheira as a healer and backup. Games Baldur's Gate 2 Walkthroughs & Guides Walkthrough by Montresor Baldur's Gate 2 Online Walkthrough by Montresor CREATING A CHARACTER | GENERAL TIPS AND. They are first encountered in Baldur's Gate II: Throne of. So, I'm on the third level of Watcher's Keep (the maze), and I'm in the room just after Tahazzar. The Flint and Tinder can be used with this oil to light the torches nearby the Machine of Lum the Mad. Watcher's Keep, BG2. If memory serves, he's one of the statues that come to live once you place the items on the altar (but before you perform the ritual). Cespenar in Throne of Bhaal can upgrade it to +5. BG2: Remorhaz, Watcher's Keep, Elemental Level Remorhaz Shell Helm BG1: Taerom Thunderhammer, Beregost, crafted from shell BG2: Cromwell or Cespenar, crafted from shell Kontik's Ring. A highlevel boosted powerfighter that does the right stuff - picks of the right things - and goes the right route in that maze, will succeed most of the time. The objective is to not take the last coin: - Take two coins. 3 comes out, as well as updates to Wheels of Prophecy and Ascension, I may play through TOB. While it was a formidable challenge, it left me wondering whether I could have done it even sooner, as one of my first quests in Chapter 2. Second Draw (First Draw was a "Bad" Draw) Bad draws: Void: User must save vs. Oh, and use wands and scrolls, too, especially any scrolls that can summon fodder. There are some other notables. Ammo belt, an bag of holding. For SoA I'd say about 3. Dispel combat protections and clobber, or dispel spell protections and blast them with things like ADHW. However, you can buy some good stuff early on (like a great crossbow, potion pouches, etc) and there are some very useful items on the first level (quiver of. Kundane +2 - Shortsword of Speed. Now, after killing Yaga-Shura and arriving in the desert. Immediately when you enter this lair, you should get an idea what awaits you inside. Cone of Cold. It was forced to help servants of Helm in securing the Imprisoned One in the Keep. Enhanced Edition > BG2: Throne of Bhaal (Classic) > Sorcerer's Place is a project run entirely by fans and for fans. BG2 - Bag of Holding BG1 - A barrel in Beregost at the south. In order to actually benefit from these items in ToB it would make sense to not postpone Watcher's Keep till the very end of ToB. It is hostile right from the beginning and attacks on sight after a quick comment. Once players have found the location of the Steel Watch Foundry, carefully watch the Steel Watchers. Fantasy. The radiance of. Stealing is not possible because the dragon is hostile and too large. Use your mage spells to lower their defenses. meaninglessINTERUPT • 4 yr. Dragon is found in a sublevel to Watcher's Keep Final Seal, and is a part of the challenges to unlock it. On my first playthrough of BG2, I kept on levelling my character, then reimporting him into a new game for whatever. If you go to the Watcher's Keep at a relatively low level, there will be less statues guarding the gate to the second level. Watcher's Keep level 2 bug? Discussion in 'BG2: Throne of Bhaal (Classic)' started by NINURTA, Jun 19, 2003. A strange being named Solar will appear and. As a Green Dragon, it has Poisonous breath and uses attacks that affect mobility and spellcasting ability. Some monsters are summoned to fight you. According to Wiki: Status Effects, you can also block the level drain effect with Barbarian Rage or with Enrage. Try and aggro one or two enemies at a time , retreat and then quickly kill the aggroed mob. He challenges you to meet him upstairs in the Room of Blood and Blades. Kill everybody using the 3 powerful enemies you have charmed (hint: if Aesgareth and the two panthers are dead there's no one else left who can ignore invisibility, making things considerably easier). BG2 is a lot longer than BG1. Traps at the later stages. I use the same tactic as volar, i just whack them with fists until they are unconscious and let sarevok hit em til he does deathbringer assault, that attack rocks, even if your using your fists it still kills em. The room is right beside lum's machine. Allow Cromwell to Upgrade Watcher's Keep Items BG2EE, EET, BG2 (requires ToB), BGT. com] #6. Have an Armor Class of -15 or lower. Exit east to the "pillar of stone/Cornugons area" Area 3008 3. The door to this crypt will start out locked. Early on, I have her use Belm + Shield (usually Harmony) and a Str belt. Altar Level, aka The Ritual Level, is the 1st level of Watcher's Keep. Immediately two statues came to life. The chest at (x=890, y=560) contains the Flint and Tinder. I place my summons on the left hand side to keep Nalmissra and the Hive Mother occupied. SoA continues into ToB automatically, and Watcher's Keep - which is part of the expansion - is available in SoA already. Accept its challenge, and it asks you a riddle. Feel free to browse our. Large Shield +2. The Watcher's Keep broken? So I finished level 3 of the Watcher's Keep some time ago, at level 15 in SoA. . If you agree to help, you will go to the entrance and he will tell you more about your quest. -Use the deck for whatever outcome you want (or don't). Gauntlets of Crushing. You have finally made it to the lowermost level of Watcher's Keep. Speak to Odren in front of Watcher's Keep. Seconding doing what you can in Watcher's Keep early. The Thieves' Hood is a unique piece of headgear that can only be equipped by thieves of all class combinations and kits. The Watcher's Keep. 0. Games; Manuals; Updates; Watcher's Keep: 3rd Level . It also made a previously unknown studio, Bioware, a name to be reckoned with. He will ask for your help in restoring the seals on the 'imprisoned one' inside the dungeon. With Bhallspawn, Korgan, Minsc(3 Berserkers), Keldorn, Yoshimo(Dualled to fighter) and Aerie, it was actually easy. Then when you turn the key, you'll open its associated lock, and you'll get attacked by something. But since completing the Iron Throne mission we can't walk through the city without the. 2-3 days ago, I was wondering if I get overwhelmed or bored by the gameplay because everything seemed too complicated. Follow the steps to complete the ritual, fight. Hello, my character's name is Kerrigan and she is a fighter (lvl 24) with GM in Long Sword/Shortbow and I assure you she has the best gear. Baldur's Gate II: Shadows of Amn. She is summoned along with Nalmissra, The Huntress , Ameralis Zauviir, a Hive Mother and Xei Win Toh when the last key of the Final Seal is turned. Best weapon proficiences for both BG1 and BG2 soloing are Scimitar + Quarterstaffs - In BG kill Drizt for his Scimitars, in BG2 you get one with an extra attack per round. Open my documents and find the baldurs gate folder. Add. There are some other notables. Jester and Sun gives 50k to user and 300k exp to party, respectively. You've seen such lairs before if you've been through Shadows of Amn. Will he open th. When you go through the portal he will talk to you, tell him you plan on reading the ritual scroll. For BG2, there is only one game in town - make a beeline for the first floor of Watcher's keep and the +3 returning crimson dart, which will be your mainstay for the rest of the game. I rule. Watcher's Keep 2 (AR3016) [Legacy Page] Did we miss anything on this map? Is there something we didn't discover? Let us know! 1 - Imprisoned Demon When you reach the second floor, you will find yourself in dialogue with a Chromatic Demon that has been imprisoned in a cell here on the second floor. Flail of Ages would become more powerful as more heads for it are attached. There are some other notables. This strategy reduces the number of attacks a mob makes on you. When you produce a globe, there are monsters that are summoned based on what globe you produce. 3) Receive new scroll from Helmite ghost. - Nov 24, 01;5. This item appears in Baldur's Gate II: Throne of Bhaal and Baldur's Gate II: Enhanced Edition. No, the only area included in both after a fresh start is the Watcher's Keep. None of the portals at 2 are working. The first zone has some goodies in it. Information on this page and that page overlap in some subjects, but both together will fill out the questline. Untouchable. At the beginning of the Compass Level, the party will meet an Elven Madman who. However, in terms of ambition and originality,. I can't kill them. For BG1:EE you have the option of: Darts of Wounding, Darts of Stunning (You can buy from sorcerous sundries or find scatter around) and a variety of +1 darts available from Thalantyr in highhedge (acid or fire damage e. 5. Keep in mind that the Skald Song does not give immunity to fear before lvl 15, meaning that you need to prepare a spell to deal with that. Spoilers starting here: Godlike. Unlike BG:EE, circlets have original inventory animations. The story so far: During SoA, I visited Watcher's Keep normally (everything went fine there) to stash some unused items in the chests in the first level (I never went further than that). Go upstairs, prepare, and enter the room. Find your way to the top of the keep and speak to Odren. Watcher's Keep has a stairway on the southwest side, aside from the one that takes you to the top, which has multiple entrances to each level of Watcher's Keep, assuming you've unlocked them. Watcher's Keep itself isn't that hard at first (some people do the. PLOT04B. Open all doors between the Air Mage's Laboratory at 6 and the Ice Mage's Laboratory. Throne of Bhall is very. Nothing hurts the succubus as far as I can tell. The player may also loot Lord Roenall's body for Full Plate Armor +1, a Bastard Sword +1, a Large Shield and some gold. - The statues come alive and attack you. White Dragon Scale functions as splint mail +6, but bards, thieves, and stalkers can wear it without disabling or penalty to thieving skills. These are also short duration effects. He will tell you that you have been tricked by false Helmites, and that when you read the Ritual Scroll you will be trapped inside along with him. Just went from watchers Keep level 2 to level 3 and encountered a MASSIVE difficulty spike. The rod is half of the key needed to open the crypt (#12). Pages: 1. Hello, my character's name is Kerrigan and she is a fighter (lvl 24) with GM in Long Sword/Shortbow and I assure you she has the best gear. When you turn the wheel in the center of the lab while holding the scepter, you'll switch the magical fan from "low" to "high," and the machinery in the lab will stop shooting lightning bolts, making it safe again. What avoiding fights by bringing a man his slippers isn't awesome? It's awesome. Comet grants +5% fire resistance permanently. All you need to do is kill one statue and you'll have made progress. Except the bag of holding, which is chapter 4. It won't fix the overall problem, but you will at least be able to access the content in the Keep. Perhaps the evil wind emanating from it!!! In any case I had a blast! Awesome and well thought out dungeon. February 2015. Let her Kiss you. My swashbuckler had -25 on the last playthrough. It's only a stopgap, but I have heard that it is possible to access Watcher's Keep using a console command. I cleaned out Watcher's Keep level 1. Website: Watch Non Stop Attack. New optional dungeon that could be accessed from both original Shadows of Amn game and Throne of Bhaal campaign: the legendary Watcher's Keep, where the great demon prince. Trademeet (which I return to later for skindancer end) Watcher's Keep level 1 including opening the portal. You now have four options: First, you can believe the Imprisoned One and agree to help him get revenge. Stealing is not possible because the dragon is hostile and too large. The center archway leads down to the Mind Flayer level (area #10). I have recently been playing through BG2 and really taking my time. The jump in quality from BG1 base game and that dungeon is amazing. I've been hitting him for minutes, and he's still shows as "Uninjured". Wanderon Member. The entrance to the Demi-Lich's tomb is southwest in the Watcher's Keep Githyanki Encampment. ago. Watchers Keep level 6 ethical dilemma (SPOILERS) Feral: Baldurs Gate II: Shadows of Amn & Throne of Bhaal: 12: 12-03-2003 02:57 PM: Watchers Keep level four help -- spoilers: Sir Jaren Tor: Baldurs Gate II:. You'll earn 40,000 xp for winning the battle, and you'll find the Air Scepter on the guardian's corpse. The Chromatic Demon is a tanar'ri demon imprisoned in Watcher's Keep. The giant keeps regenerate. spells. Posted September 16, 2013. When you place the three items on the altar, some of the statues at 8 will come to life and attack you. Old Slippers are a pair of boots which grant a percentage of cold resistance to the wearer. It also went on to say that Robert the fence has a potion bag in the temple sewers. With that info, I created a BG2:EE installation without the BagBonus mod I usually install (that adds a potion case and a ammo belt to Deidre in the Adventurer's Mart). Also avoid if you lack a thief with max trap detection. For the second game, you'll draw Guile (attacked by six assassins) or Strength (stat-cursed), while Aesgareth will draw Defiance or Empress. 5 to 7 million if I do Watcher's Keep. A particular room is full of demons, the unique one Tahazzar, that I need to kill to advance the storyline, and with magic being neutered, I am getting destroyed. That dungeon is indeed fantastic, and would make my top list for sure. The best Shortbow is either Tuigan +1 (gives -1/+1 and an extra APR) or Gesen (gives -4/+2+1d8, avg +6. I'd say about twice as long, especially if you include Watcher's Keep which is an absolutely enormous dungeon. 2 - Insane Elf. The Thieves' Hood is a unique piece of headgear that can only be equipped by thieves of all class combinations and kits. Ask A Question. This is the diary of an apprentice of Carston, the mad mage in the Machine of Lum the Mad. 16. It'll require you to pick up Blue Oil (#4), Purple Oil (#15), Red Oil (#12), and a Flint and Tinder (#13). 4) Enter the keep and kill Demogorgon (100k XP). Other Areas: 2nd Level 4th Level: Treasures: T1 (AR3011): Madman's Journal Gold and Gems Long Sword; 5. Advice for Succubi. To cheat it in, first find your baldur. See moreA comprehensive guide to the Watcher's Keep dungeon in Baldur's Gate 2 Online, where you can find The Imprisoned One and a scroll to seal off the keep. akbar. ;) Post edited March 12, 2013 by Hickory. The only thing I have found which does any damage at all is insect plague. Watcher's Keep riddle . The Slime Mage's poison is blown into the Ice Mage's Laboratory, weakening his creatures. The diary explains that to shatter the crystal and let Carston out, you must strike the crystal six times with a Crystal Mallet. t. BGII:ToB, BGII:EE. It can still fire chosen projectiles in the quiver, if the wielder wants this. I cannot kill the ice golems, and cannot even get the poison vapours to shift over to them. On my first playthrough of BG2, I kept on levelling my character, then reimporting him into a new game for whatever. **Edit** Just found out you mean Nightmare mode, I was referring to the highest "regular" mode called Insane. Baldur's Gate 3 FAQ; Forum: Baldur's Gate 3; Icewind Dale. Typically you'd do it in Chapter 3 or 6 if Multi, Chapter 6 if Solo (because of the Bag of Holding). The more globes you produce, the stronger the monsters. The encounters on levels 3-5 are far stronger than anything in SoA. However. Not saying it CAN'T be done at 14, but it's gonna be difficult. Watcher's Keep Lvl 2 Fire Giant: ibrocks: Baldurs Gate II: Shadows of Amn & Throne of Bhaal: 4: 12-14-2001 08:27 PM: fire giant in watchers keep: BRB: Baldurs Gate II: Shadows of Amn & Throne of Bhaal: 3: 06-28-2001 09:17 PM: All times are GMT -4. This item, which you can loot from Aesgareth at 35 on the Maze level of Watcher's Keep, deserves a page on its own; if only because the Item Description is rather long. You can travel to Watcher's Keep during chapters 2, 3, and 6 in Shadows of Amn, and during chapters 8 (after you have escaped Saradush) and 9 in Throne of Bhaal. Typically you'd do it in Chapter 3 or 6 if Multi, Chapter 6 if Solo (because of the Bag of Holding). Didn’t work. Certain characters are immune to Level Drain, such as the Undead Hunter (Paladin kit). Iirc watchers keep is balanced assuming that you do it after finishing SoA and before you’re too deep into ToB. You'll emerge on the third floor of Watcher's Keep at this location. We also feature mods for Neverwinter Nights II. yeah, level 5 and 6 are really made for teams that are in ToB, but I have beaten watchers keep while in SoA, but that was eons again, I usually don't start watchers keep until I hit ToB because it can just make your characters way to powerful for SoA. It has +3 bonus to THAC0, it inflicts 1d10+3 points of damage, weighs 3 lbs. You now have four options: First, you can believe the Imprisoned One and agree to help him get revenge. Other Areas: Outside 2nd Level: Treasures:. Baldurs Gate II Archives: 8: 12-02-2000 03:25 AM: All times are GMT -4. Foebane +3. You'll win if you draw Strength but lose if you draw Guile. . If you agree to help, you will go to the entrance and he will tell you more about your quest. Congratulations! You have reached the last level but one of Watcher's Keep. Let us know! 1 - Arrival. The Imprisoned One opens a breach in the seal, allowing you to use the portals. Belm + one found in watchers keep are the best. Basically, it's all won thanks to Keldorns dispel magic, which works at twice the normal level due to him being an inquisitor, some focus fire and mordenkainen kiting. In the center of this area, you will find the portal to the 2nd level. A strange being named Solar will appear and. There is six torches and I have three colors, red, blue, and purple. Ever been looting Watcher's Keep during Shadows of Amn and say to yourself "Darn, if only Cromwell would do something with these white dragon scales. GreenWarlock Posts: 1,354. I usually use EEKeeper to change Imoen back into a pure Thief for my BG2 playthroughs. The most similar design was Watcher's Keep, though the one I came closest to getting the same feeling from was probably the Planar Sphere quest; in the sense of slowly piecing together what had really happened, and understanding the man responsible. Follow the steps to complete the ritual, fight the enemies, and loot the items in this guide for Baldur's Gate II: Enhanced Edition on PS4. You'll earn 40,000 xp for winning the battle, and you'll find the Air Scepter on the guardian's corpse. Click on one of the stone heads and the Forest Spirit will speak to you, giving you a hint of what is to come. 5). Either by potions, crom faeyr or Draw Upon Holy Might. They. Then remove them from the party atop WK. Watcher's Keep Chromatic Demon [Session 161, Part 5 of 5]. The Ulitharid drops an Illithid Rod. 'Program Options' 'Debug Mode' '1'. I ran to a room and closed the door to gather my. Baldur's Gate was a revelation in CRPGs in 1998 with unparalleled world building, writing and strategic depth. Either one will work, but I'll let you decide on which scroll to use. I found a Lich and a party on a house at bridge district. Features []. 2) Exit and lure the Helmites into the keep to get slaughtered (25k XP). Watcher's Keep Level 3 maze: Read the Madman's Journal to learn about how to get through the maze by the most direct method: 1. Level 4 starts with some Illithids and is followed by some Gith. )The most notable aspect of the expansion I will remember is the many tough battles. You will also find the dungeon and many new areas on the new BGII: ToB map if you choose to start the next chapter in the Child of Bhaal storyline. Even after leaving Watcher's Keep it still does not show up on my map so I would have to do the work around again to get back. Each of them drops mundane stuff and a Potion of Extra Healing. The entrance area of Watcher's Keep, this is where you'll arrive from the world map travel. The center archway leads down to the Mind Flayer level (area #10). But he's friendly. All of the online walkthroughs tell you how to beat the level and go to level 4, NONE tell you how to go to. Baldur's Gate II: Enhanced Edition. death at -4 penalty or be disintegrated. You could also cast your preparation spells two areas back, to avoid the null magic area. baldursgate. For opening the seal, each party member receives 20,000 XP. You'll earn 45,000 xp for defeating them, and you'll find an Illithid Rod when you loot their corpses. You will immediately be under attack from several Githyanki. These key battles can be very tough, so it's a good idea to buff up before turning any keys. When you enter the room at 6, Lassal faces you one more time. Best of luck, though. If the user is multi-class, the spellcasting class is favored. Clear out this level as well, and don't forget to loot the room at 5. The Imprisoned One will speak to you as soon as you arrive in the 6th level of Watcher's Keep. I then have Avastrian use the Heart Key on the pedestal in order to start combat. This is where you'll arrive after traveling to Watcher's Keep on the overhead map. booinyoureyes Member Posts: 6,164. Aesgareth is a demon (chaotic evil / chaotic neutral ) who at some point left his own Plane and ended up getting trapped inside Watcher's Keep. Sister Garlena is a Knight of the Vigil whose task, along with the other knights, was to keep the 'Imprisoned One' trapped in Watcher's Keep. To the file (with tabs between the quoted phrases) Save, then follow the instruction above. But to do that, you'll have to open three partial seals. Maps, items, NPCs, shops list with inventory, various tips & tricks, character creation - you'll find it all and more covered by this extensive guide. continue to explore the temple on the first level of Watcher's Keep. Randomize the maze in Watcher's Keep (BG2, BG2EE, BGT EET) This component is for the benefit of people who've now basically got the Watcher's Keep teleport maze memorized. ~CDTWEAKS/SETUP-CDTWEAKS. Ending ToB might be like 6. Learn how to create a. Dagger +3. Level 1 - The Ritual Chambers. Warrick. The Gauntlets of Extraordinary Specialization, found very low down in Watchers Keep, can add . Baldur's Gate II Online Solution by Sylvus Moonbow : N/A: ReadLevel 3 is filled with demons and portals. When you turn the wheel in the center of the lab while holding the scepter, you'll. Just a small stride up from your initial position, you'll meet. There are traps under each arch, including the one you walk through to enter the room. . -Don't know if the directions are entirely correct here (kinda hard to go from memory. No, of course not! ;. Watcher's Keep can be done as early as Chapter 2 in BG2. Like the helm, they can be found on the second floor of Watcher's Keep. Publisher: Interplay. Nor on the poor inmates in Spellhold. Your party will be awarded 25,000 experience points as soon as the new scroll is in your hands. It is hostile right from the beginning and attacks on sight after a quick comment. But now I have advanced the plot till the start of chapter 3 and I still failed to find a merchant. Life is measured not by the breaths you take but by the moments that take your breath away. You can create it via the console or add it to your inventory via Shadowkeeper. Maps, items, NPCs, shops list with inventory, various tips & tricks, character creation - you'll find it all and more covered by this extensive guide. On the last area of the third level of Watcher's Keep, you will find Aesgareth. I went to watchers keep to verify (found a potion bag). Or playing a dual-class Fighter(kit)>Mage and gaining extra XP from re-learning known spells from scrolls. Put your party somwhere in the middle of the big stairs and turn the AI off. Luckily I'm not playing no-reload, and gave up on minimal a while back. Turning on the fan. I've been really enjoying the battles in the maze as they really offer a nice challenge, and in interesting ways. Since this is a fairly difficult dungeon, I suggest that you wait until Throne of Bhaal. Game crashes in dead magic room. " - Smiling Jack. Each time you insert a key into one of the pedestals surrounding the seal, each character in your party will earn 20,000 xp. The. When I boot BG2 EE I choose between Shadow of Amn, Throne of Baal and Black Pits 2. That might sound fun, but it's a bit annoying. The Candle is a quest item needed in Watcher's Keep for the ceremony on the first floor. Some monsters are summoned to fight you. Thanks for this. The armor weighs 15 lbs. Enemies:. Ka'rashur is a devil found in Watcher's Keep Compass Level. On arrival an Imp speaks to you. They are immune to magic weapons and spells but can be harmed with any non-magical weapon or attack. I played through the game a thousand times and always seemed to ignore it. It used to be be a TOB extra, but with EE, you can access it during SOA. Or just loot the upper floors and be done with it. Damage from this effect can be halved by making a successful save vs. Open in text editor. Storm Star +5. Add. The Composite Longbow +2 is marginally better.